Local discovery-corpus v3 verification

The candidate adds a generic source-bound discovery and relationship loader on the approved Explorer base ea485af6f5c20ba32e63772cc8e851dd44239e2b. See the architecture decision for the exact producer contract and fixed ranking parameters.

Checks completed

Initial local checks at 770cab5b: 713 application unit tests, 31 focused v3 controls within that suite, nine schema/evaluation tests, 12 archive tests and 92 service tests pass. Svelte reports zero errors and warnings. The deterministic application build has tree SHA-256 4b923c9d9ad4e4c65bf4dcc97864d9dabac4bae49008b96b8d13a1ae486e5dc2 and manifest SHA-256 6b4eea60cc8cc1f9522ab9b506f17daa70ab839ec15fb50dbff31e05143a1d96. Documentation lockstep, British English and whitespace checks pass.

• Generic source/card controls exercise exact multi-page units, separate ranking channels, actual concept resolution, directed dependencies outside the lexical shortlist, stale whole-record bindings, corrupted or missing cards, inconsistent graph commitments, resource limits and complete bounded reconstruction.
• The additional gzip control verifies compressed cards and rejects expansion beyond the declared decoded-byte binding.
• The existing Reader adapter admits v3 through its lazy, hash-bound context_corpus entrypoint. Reader loading and context loading remain separate.
• Existing v1 replay inputs and expected package are unchanged. A synthetic v2 fixture captured using the approved base replays the full package exactly, including its cross-page spans, dependency and context identifier.
• Offline schema controls reject changed ranking parameters, mixed channel order, evidence masquerading as a card, official card status, missing bindings, fractional frequencies and incomplete direction declarations.
• The 12 existing archive controls pass, including actual retained historical packages. The 92 service tests pass with frozen engines and approved sources retained. These checks do not admit v3 to a deployed remote service.
• Independent read-only review found no blocker and independently ran the then 30 new generic controls. Its suggested gzip control was subsequently added and passed. It also recommended measuring discovery diagnostic bytes separately in the domain experiment, because 16 full cards can exhaust a small package.

Retained failure and correction

The first service run passed 91 of 92 tests. Its relocation test could not find the new corpusV3.ts import in its copied source tree. The explicit fixture inventory now includes that dependency, and all 92 tests pass, including exact Worker/Node build identity with real and linked dependencies. The separate observation build-input allowlist also includes the new module. Frozen engine manifests and historical receipts were not edited.

Dependencies were installed from the existing lockfile and local npm cache, offline, with install scripts disabled. No provider, model, acquisition or external service calls were made for these checks.

What these checks do not establish

These are local implementation and compatibility checks. They do not establish complete domain coverage, source interpretation, source freshness, legal or specialist acceptance, answer quality, affordability or measured performance on the full manual. A public application release, exact deployed browser journey, remote engine/source admission and client acceptance remain separate work.

The producer experiment must report source/card/heading coverage, source and discovery ranking contributions, candidate and dependency retention, diagnostic bytes, transferred/decoded bytes, exact delivery reads and unresolved obligations. Keep the questions and source fixed before comparing outcomes; do not tune the declared baseline ranking parameters to those questions.

Full-corpus feedback and candidate correction

The first DWP producer experiment used engine 770cab5b and retained all forty questions at both budgets. It exposed two limitations: repeated full-card metadata prevented useful 32 KiB inline results, and eager lexical hydration spent the shared 64-file allowance before two declared concept paths finished. The original result remains a failed acceptance attempt, not a replaced success.

The next candidate gives already resolved concepts' outgoing paths priority and returns exact card/incident metadata references, with separately bounded read helpers. Neither ranking parameters nor resource limits change. Generic controls recover complete lazy metadata and reject altered hashes, IDs, ordinals and counts; source units and every reported obligation remain separate. 720 application tests, ten schema checks and Svelte checking pass locally. Independent review found no blocker. The subsequently added regression confirms that a unit first reached at maximum concept depth can later act as a shallower lexical seed, without counting its edges or diagnostics twice; all 39 focused discovery controls pass with that addition.

A development observation over the same DWP manifest restores the two reported path regressions at 512 KiB, without claiming an answer or completeness. Small 32 KiB inline contexts still refuse metadata honestly; larger assembly followed by exact bounded reads remains necessary for these cases. The independent final forty-case observation belongs to the DWP repository and remains a separate gate.

Preserved CI failure

Draft PR 144's first CI run, 35793799419, passed the app, remote service, documentation and release-policy checks. Its context-execution and Python contract jobs correctly rejected old current-app receipts: the study-club receipt pinned the preceding implementation and the Heritage receipt pinned the preceding app build. pre-v3/ preserves that execution and the three Heritage receipt files unchanged. The next refresh must execute the current engine and actual browser journeys; rebinding old observations would not satisfy the gate.

That refresh has now run against the candidate app: all 100 Heritage questions meet the suite's 80-point threshold (mean 92.6), and all three local interaction journeys pass. The current receipt binds those new observations to app tree d3420a7e2673d6f172fc6f53a3f70e603b6fdfcefcf670ce3b681b90c3871397 and manifest b04036e1774f6ee7b5a6e3f764ac645ac26d3f53b3dc7741dc2fb5fc81e24220. The study-club execution was freshly run with the candidate implementation; its complete v1 context package remains byte-equivalent to the retained package. These are actual local observations, not a public v3 deployment or DWP acceptance.

The first local receipt-refresh invocation could not install an uncached dependency offline. The unchanged lockfile was verified against the existing locked project environment, which then executed the refresh successfully. No dependency version was changed. The independent review's first test invocation also unintentionally entered broader browser/listener checks; macOS sandbox permissions refused those listeners. Its direct focused rerun is recorded separately from the successful authorised browser observation above.

Separate scoped-route increment

After the allocation correction was frozen at 58776a79, DWP's unchanged-source run retained all 47 declared paths at 512 KiB and all 82 legacy v2 packages were byte-identical. Its 40 v3 questions still returned metadata refusals at 32 KiB. Those observations are retained by the DWP producer and do not establish legal answerability. They preceded the separate routing-guard change described below.

The optional guard increment prevents a shared-topic route from activating without all its declared question concepts. Synthetic controls distinguish two fictional activities, lexical matches, ambiguous or reached concepts, malformed and unavailable identifiers, required-path gaps and forged loader diagnostics. The first v2 guard test attempted a new question against a replay fixture that stored only its original posting shards; it failed closed on the missing file. The separate test fixture now explicitly supplies its other empty buckets; the retained replay and source files were not changed.

pre-guards/ preserves the allocation candidate's study-club and Heritage observations. Its observed_at was corrected from a local-time transcription to the actual UTC clock, without changing any browser-result or app hash. A fresh guarded-app observation is required before its current-app receipt is published.

The guarded runtime is checkpointed at c19912ba. Its 743 application tests, 11 schema controls, 12 archive tests, nine archive transport controls and Svelte checking pass. Independent review reran all 61 focused discovery/guard controls after repairing the identified explanation-integrity issue; the review receipt retains that finding and exact hashes. The current v1 package remains byte-equivalent, and retained unguarded v2 replay passes.

The guarded app's fresh browser observation also passes all 100 Heritage questions (mean 92.6) and all three journeys. Its tree SHA-256 is 318c218c5b9d321e7a240e0370ad152ec5ec5bd6716f5301ddb9779374ae816c and manifest SHA-256 is 0595a30c57c7255f6f07f7a52603ebb1b9c0e2ab4ce310419fa6835a22d50656. The first Site assembly attempt used a plain Vite build without the canonical build manifest and correctly failed verification. The governed deterministic build then produced that manifest; the repeated Site assembly and actual browser observation passed. This refresh does not establish final DWP acceptance or public runtime adoption.

Final-corpus allocation checks and retained regressions

The larger source-led DWP corpus exposed a further competition between graph metadata and complete evidence. Its trial 03 retained all 47 inherited declared paths, but one question returned no source evidence at 512 KiB. Shared file limits could be spent before a lexical source was read, and large unused incident rows could force whole evidence units out of the inline package.

The af5f5183 candidate admitted one complete lexical source before actual concept traversal and omitted unused inline relationship rows under byte pressure. Omission IDs and committed incident metadata remained inspectable; selected and required paths were protected. Generic controls and a new actual Heritage browser run passed, but DWP trial 04 lost an inherited declared path (46 of 47 retained). That domain regression remains a failed acceptance attempt. pre-admission-balance/ preserves the preceding candidate receipts, and pre-path-priority/ preserves the af5f5183 observations. The latter also retains a mistaken local journey URL invocation; its corrected invocation passed all three journeys. No test expectation was weakened to discard that failure.

The separately reviewed 8a5b8d11 candidate gives applicable declared paths priority only after their exact, guarded edge prefixes are observed from an actually resolved concept. Requirements do not create edges or seed evidence. Prefix work is bounded at 2,000 and exhaustion remains explicit. Integrity-bound whole units with unresolved boundaries can be retained for review; their existing boundary warnings and insufficient status remain. Ranking parameters and all existing transport limits are unchanged.

Local checks on this candidate pass: 750 application tests, including 68 focused discovery and guard controls; 11 Python schema/evaluation controls; and Svelte with zero errors and warnings. Documentation, British English and whitespace checks pass. A fresh study-club execution preserves the full retained v1 package, and the retained v2 replay control passes. The independent path-prefix review records the exact code bindings and boundaries; the preceding allocation review is also retained.

Its deterministic app build has tree SHA-256 430fbf5477e0d8f7597ac745e1d84b289e4c519751a12c6c9ee42d459196c662 and manifest SHA-256 57a05e96c5d8e4265ab22b0c2f5fc5a5d4d942ce950ffee7c1e6c118f06f940e. All 100 actual local Heritage questions pass the 80-point threshold (mean 92.6), and all three interaction journeys pass. The current receipt binds those new observations; its four materialisation controls pass.

DWP trial 05 is now independently accepted for the runtime allocation scope, retained at source checkpoint 159da46e09c06d11e300a7d1d2568983e54025ee: all 40 questions retain source evidence at 512 KiB, all 47 inherited and 181 new declared source-read paths remain, and all 82 legacy packages are byte-identical. The independent audit validated 2,723 retained traversal paths and confirmed that 354 explicit inline-edge omissions removed no required path edge. All packages remain insufficient; this is evidence retention, not answerability. A separate Reader observation found a producer endpoint-catalogue limit; its producer-only repair and the next source release need their own actual browser acceptance. Neither these checks nor the static application release admits the source or engine to the remote Ask OKF service.